BroomstackBuddy vs spreadsheets
Running your curling club on spreadsheets?
Most clubs start with a spreadsheet, and for good reason: it's free, flexible and everyone knows how to use one. The trouble starts when the schedule, the dues list and the standings live in different files that only one volunteer understands.
Side by side
| Task | Spreadsheets | BroomstackBuddy |
|---|---|---|
| League schedule | Spreadsheets: Built by hand, usually by one person, and rebuilt when a team drops out | BroomstackBuddy: Generated from your draw times, sheets, blackout dates and each team's draw preferences |
| Balanced opponents and sheets | Spreadsheets: Checked by eye, if at all | BroomstackBuddy: Every pair meets evenly; sheets and draw times are spread for each team |
| Scores and standings | Spreadsheets: Retyped from scorecards, with formulas that break when rows move | BroomstackBuddy: Entered end by end; standings and tiebreakers update when a game is final |
| Dues and registration | Spreadsheets: A sign-up sheet, plus cash, cheques and e-transfers matched up by the treasurer | BroomstackBuddy: Members register and pay by card online; cash and cheques are recorded in the same place |
| Bonspiel draws | Spreadsheets: A whiteboard or a template copied from last year | BroomstackBuddy: A/B/C events or pools, with draws and sheets assigned and brackets that advance themselves |
| Sharing with members | Spreadsheets: Emailed attachments, often out of date by the next week | BroomstackBuddy: Live on your club website and in members' calendars |
| When the volunteer moves on | Spreadsheets: The knowledge often leaves with them | BroomstackBuddy: Everything stays in one system the next manager can pick up |
| Cost | Spreadsheets: Free | BroomstackBuddy: Free for clubs up to 50 active members; larger clubs from $15 a month |
When you might not need us
Not every club needs club software. Spreadsheets may be all you need if:
- You run one small league with the same teams every week and no draw preferences.
- One person enjoys doing the schedule and will be around for years.
- Dues are collected once, in person, at the start of the season.
Questions clubs ask
- Can we import our current spreadsheet?
- Mention it in your demo request and we'll talk through bringing your members, teams and leagues across.
- Can we still export data?
- Yes. Reports can be exported, so your treasurer can keep using the spreadsheet they like for the books.
- Is it hard for older members to use?
- Members mostly use your club website: find their draws, check standings, register and pay. If they can shop online, they can register for a league.
- What does it cost?
- BroomstackBuddy is free for clubs up to 50 active members. Larger clubs pay by club size, from $15 a month or $150 a year, with no setup fee. Card payments go to your club's own Stripe account at Stripe's standard rate, and BroomstackBuddy adds nothing on top. Every plan is on the pricing page.
More comparisons
Let's talk about your club
Tell us a little about your club and we'll walk you through BroomstackBuddy with your own leagues in mind. It's free for clubs up to 50 active members, and there's no commitment. See pricing